Is Profibus a good industrial bus actually, a good solution?

H

Haritztolete

Jan 1, 1970
0
Hello everybody. I know this is a technical question and first of all
some things should be explained. I think that if we need to communicate
a lot of data in the bus it is clear that Ethernet (TCP-IP) is a much
more better solution, but if there is not so much information to
communicate in the bus, is still Profibus-DP a good solution? Which are
the industrial alternatives to Profibus-DP? What I am really asking for
is, is Profibus-DP decliving?
 
J

Joerg

Jan 1, 1970
0
Haritztolete wrote:

Hello everybody. I know this is a technical question and first of all
some things should be explained. I think that if we need to communicate
a lot of data in the bus it is clear that Ethernet (TCP-IP) is a much
more better solution, but if there is not so much information to
communicate in the bus, is still Profibus-DP a good solution? Which are
the industrial alternatives to Profibus-DP? What I am really asking for
is, is Profibus-DP decliving?

Just my personal opinion: Unless there is a compelling reason I try to
stay with widely accepted standards and in networking that is Ethernet.
This is how we rigged up the last production (100+ employees, lots of
machines).

Regards, Joerg
 
T

T

Jan 1, 1970
0
I have used Profibus and it does a good job. Rockwells Controlnet would be
an equivalent and FieldBus
I think although havent used FB. Ethernet is good too, however my personal
opinion is that if you utilize an ethernet based control system, someone
WILL attached devices to that network (rogue wireless accesspoints,
printers, other unplanned IP adresses) and can very possibly compromise the
security of the system, or and at worst cause unsafe or dangerous
operations. Be VERY careful how you implement any safety controls (i.e.
hardwire safety controls directly) and assume the ethernet is down when
developing safety shutdown controls. You as the designer assume
responsibility for loss of profits or life due the incapacitation of your
network. For these reasons I would use non ethernet based control networks
after careful analysis. Communication of data alone is a different issue and
ethernet is the way to go. Just my opinion.
 
Top