Frequency detector in PLL design

J

joe

Jan 1, 1970
0
Anyone knows about the frequency detector to aid acquisition in IC design of
a PLL. Lots of publication talks about the phase detector, but they only
give a "box" to indicate a FD. That's all. It seems like it is too simple
to show the detail. But I had a hard time to find a good schematic through
all my sources.

I would appreciate if you can let me know some basic schematic or topology
of a FD, or sources of FDs.
 
R

Rene Tschaggelar

Jan 1, 1970
0
joe said:
Anyone knows about the frequency detector to aid acquisition in IC design of
a PLL. Lots of publication talks about the phase detector, but they only
give a "box" to indicate a FD. That's all. It seems like it is too simple
to show the detail. But I had a hard time to find a good schematic through
all my sources.

I would appreciate if you can let me know some basic schematic or topology
of a FD, or sources of FDs.

Many solutions use PLLS with phase detector already built in but
require an external VCO. The Analog Devices PLL chips work like that.

There are even PLL chips that have PLL and VCO built in.

There are a few specialized PLL-phasedetectors or at least they
claim it to be. Basically you can take a mixer for sine waves, or an
XOR gate for digital signals.

What output signal, sine or digital did you have in mind ? What frequency
range from what reference ? What is the required phase noise ?

Rene
 
J

joe

Jan 1, 1970
0
Flip-flop and/or XOR are typically used in the phase detector. For example,
the Hogge phase detector.
So, what's the major difference between the phase detector and frequency
detector. although I know some
are even called phase-frequency detectors(PFD). Frequency detector is
assumed to provide lock aid to the PLL,
but how?

To answer your question, I don't care much about the waveform shape at the
output at this stage (not frequency
or phase noise either). I just wonder how a FD helps get a quicker lock in
or, maybe wider locking range. And how is a good FD.

thanks!

Joe
 
A

Allan Herriman

Jan 1, 1970
0
Anyone knows about the frequency detector to aid acquisition in IC design of
a PLL. Lots of publication talks about the phase detector, but they only
give a "box" to indicate a FD. That's all. It seems like it is too simple
to show the detail. But I had a hard time to find a good schematic through
all my sources.

I would appreciate if you can let me know some basic schematic or topology
of a FD, or sources of FDs.

The ubiquitous 4046 contains a frequency detector as part of PD2.
Datasheets usually include the internal schematic.

It's not very sophisticated. If one input has transitions more often
than the other, the output must be pulling one way *on average*.

Regards,
Allan.
 
J

John Popelish

Jan 1, 1970
0
joe said:
Anyone knows about the frequency detector to aid acquisition in IC design of
a PLL. Lots of publication talks about the phase detector, but they only
give a "box" to indicate a FD. That's all. It seems like it is too simple
to show the detail. But I had a hard time to find a good schematic through
all my sources.

I would appreciate if you can let me know some basic schematic or topology
of a FD, or sources of FDs.

The two common phase detector types are pretty well explained in the
data sheet for the 4046:

http://www.fairchildsemi.com/ds/CD/CD4046BC.pdf
 
J

Jim Thompson

Jan 1, 1970
0
The ubiquitous 4046 contains a frequency detector as part of PD2.
Datasheets usually include the internal schematic.

It's not very sophisticated. If one input has transitions more often
than the other, the output must be pulling one way *on average*.

Regards,
Allan.

Of course it's not sophisticated... it just works... just another copy
of the original Treadway/Thompson PFD.

...Jim Thompson
 
A

Allan Herriman

Jan 1, 1970
0
Of course it's not sophisticated... it just works... just another copy
of the original Treadway/Thompson PFD.

Jim,
I didn't mean to disparage the design; I was merely trying to point
out to the OP that it should be simple to understand.

Regards,
Allan.
 
J

joe

Jan 1, 1970
0
Good! It makes sense. Thanks!

Two more questions (please)
1. Any example (transistor-level or logic diagram) for this phase
comparator II (frequence detector)
2. How to realize the internal switch (built on chip), which switch the two
phase comparators (PD and PFD).

Thanks!
 
J

John Popelish

Jan 1, 1970
0
joe said:
Good! It makes sense. Thanks!

Two more questions (please)
1. Any example (transistor-level or logic diagram) for this phase
comparator II (frequence detector)

I think this data sheet goes into more detail on a similar detector:
http://www.maxim-ic.com/appnotes.cfm/appnote_number/1130/ln/en
A different version is on page 6 of:
http://www.national.com/an/AN/AN-210.pdf
Search google for ["phase locked loop" detector "charge pump"].
2. How to realize the internal switch (built on chip), which switch the two
phase comparators (PD and PFD).

The above application note shows one example. I think you could use
CMOS analog switches like those on a CD4066 or CD4016 to implement a
low frequency version.
 
J

Jim Thompson

Jan 1, 1970
0
Jim,
I didn't mean to disparage the design; I was merely trying to point
out to the OP that it should be simple to understand.

Regards,
Allan.

No worry, I didn't feel disparaged. I am a serious subscriber to the
KISS principle.

...Jim Thompson
 
Top