Watson said:
[snip]
There is a small problem with set theory here Rich; also your choice
of
words leaves something to be desired - for your assertion to hold,
smoking would need to be the ONLY cause for cancer. Best not to think
about Benzene (hey, isnt that in cigarette smoke?), xylene, toluene
etc.
No, it is benzpyrene. AFAICT, all those couldn't exist in the smoke
because they would've been burned up in the combustion.
http://www.online-medical-dictionary.org/3,4-Benzpyrene.asp?q=3,4-Benz
pyrene
[snip]
I'll give you a hint:
"for your assertion to hold, smoking would need to be the ONLY cause for
cancer. Best not to think about Benzene, Xylene or Toluene"
All of which are carcinogens we encounter daily (its in unleaded
petrol), in direct contradiction to the requirement for smoking to be
the ONLY cause of cancer. Likewise we probably better ignore ultraviolet
radiation - skin cancer etc etc.
Although you are quite correct that none of the 3 would survive in
cigarette smoke as they are highly flammable. I just seemed to remember
reading something about benzene-like nasties in cigarette smoke, hence
the aside which perhaps obfuscated the sentence, but thanks for the info.
Sick building syndrome was a big hoopla back in those days. With all
the energy conservation hysteria, they started sealing up air leaks,
which caused the air to become stale and stagnant, and _everything_
that goes into the air stays, and hangs there, forever. From alpha-
emitting radon to dust mite feces, the air was loading up with
carcinogenic pollutants.
So what do they do? In their zeal to "clean up the air," they banned
tobacco smoke.
This is exactly the wrong thing to do. What banning tobacco smoke
does is, it removes the best possible indicator of poor ventilation.
They got rid of the visible smoke, so the benzene, formaldehyde,
all manner of volatile organic hydrocarbons, bacterial spores,
fungal spores, viral spores, active viruses, live bacteria, carbon
monoxide, hydrogen sulfide, radon, dust mite feces, dust mites,
dust, human effluvia, etc, etc, etc, built up.
And the motherfuckers _still_ blame smoking for all their ills.
Stupid motherfucking nazi assholes.
Thanks,
Rich