***Including state, comunity(city) and health
I totaly agree that there has to be fairness in the system. Although,
to me is seems like $500/month is more like a slave contract. (If that
is full time.)
I just picked round numbers as an example. You can pick what ever number
you like, $500/month, $500/year, $500/day; the fact stands the system is set
up more as a trap than a help.
I agree in your main point, but look at it slightly different.
You need a certain amount just to survive, then to have some quality
in life etc. Meaning that the less you make the more your next dollar
will count, and vice versa. If you have a high income, you do not get
the same pleasure of another fistfull of dollars.
My ideal system is a flat rate with a pretty large deduction that is
given to everybody. Also, the tax rate should be the same no matter
where your income comes from (work/capital)
IOW, all animals are equal some animals are more equal than others. In your
system you are rewarding people for being poor and punishing those who work
harder than others.
Would it be fair if your boss gave everyone a bonus but he gives you less
because you make more because your job requires more skill than the guy who
sweeps the floor for minimum wage?
When there are a lot of deduction, there are often many loopholes that
are used by the rich and not by the poor/average.
Then you have the same system as today. The politicians having the ability
to use the system to buy votes. Who do you think would have the better
chance of be elected:
Pol #1: If elected I will raise the deduction for so that the workers can
have more money in their pockets AND will set the new definition of rich to
$500,000 per year to make sure the rich pay their fair share.
Pol #2: If elected I will work for a system that encourages people to raise
themselves up, to do this I will allow the hard working business people to
keep the same percentage of their money as their employees.
BTW, I have NEVER seen a poor person hiring employees (unless you count the
huge number of government workers out there 'helping' them.)