DIY DDS Function Generator or Not

D

D from BC

Jan 1, 1970
0
I almost bought a HP 20Mhz synthesizer func gen.
which totaled up to $300.00 on Eprey.

It's so old.... it's got a 7 segment LED display. :p
It's so old...my hobby electronics are more high tech :p
It's so old...I feel sorry for the guy that won the bid.

I find it hard to justify spending $300.00 when a ~$30.00 2.7Ghz DDS
chip can probably make a wider range function generator.
http://www.analog.com/UploadedFiles/Data_Sheets/281281998AD9956_a.pdf

Question is...
Is it worthwhile to make a DIY DDS based function generator?


D from BC
 
R

Robert Lacoste

Jan 1, 1970
0
D from BC said:
I almost bought a HP 20Mhz synthesizer func gen.
which totaled up to $300.00 on Eprey.

It's so old.... it's got a 7 segment LED display. :p
It's so old...my hobby electronics are more high tech :p
It's so old...I feel sorry for the guy that won the bid.

I find it hard to justify spending $300.00 when a ~$30.00 2.7Ghz DDS
chip can probably make a wider range function generator.
http://www.analog.com/UploadedFiles/Data_Sheets/281281998AD9956_a.pdf

Question is...
Is it worthwhile to make a DIY DDS based function generator?

As an example :
http://www.circuitcellar.com/library/print/0501/lacoste130/index.asp
 
E

Ecnerwal

Jan 1, 1970
0
D from BC said:
Is it worthwhile to make a DIY DDS based function generator?

Depends. If you are patient, you can get one at a better price simply by
sticking around and finding a week when nobody's bidding on them - at
least that *eventually* worked for me, and my cutoff point was a lot
lower than $300, so I let a whole bunch go for more money than I was
willing to put into them. I specifically did not want new and Chinese,
and I'm quite happy with my 3325A, LEDs and all. I have not found old
age to be an evil thing in well-built equipment, and 20 (up to 70,
actually, with some limitations) MHz is not a problem for my current
anticipated uses. I do wonder when I'm ever going to make use of the
0.000001 Hz end of the range; I am happy to have it, however, having run
into a situation with a client's generator where something below its 5
Hz bottom end would have been useful. It does a far better sweep, too.

Plenty of 3325s selling for well below $300. Don't actually see any
recent ones that got bid on (ie, more than one bid) selling for that
much. Couple with high starting prices that did get bought for $325 and
$399 with a single bid or BIN. One a couple of weeks back did get bid to
$301, but plenty selling a bit above and even a bit below $200 (not
really with shipping) in the past week. Also plenty of volume to
indicate that another will be along if you don't get the one you want at
the price you want to pay, if you can stand to wait.

Point being, by the time you've built the controls, power supplies,
output amps, connectors, boxes, etc. for your $30 chip, you'll probably
have spent more money on it. It will be newer, and perhaps it will go
faster, but the old one is a fully built system with a well-fleshed-out
user interface, etc. You can get new China junk to 20Mhz for $200 or
less, if you're willing to go there. Building your own, unless you're
sitting around looking for ways to fill your time, is something to do
for the experience or the bragging rights, or else to design the thing
well enough that you can sell them (built, as kits, board and a parts
list...) and make money at it - otherwise it's not "worthwhile". It need
only be "worthwhile" in one of those areas to be worth doing - it can be
a non-economical experiential job, for instance. And perhaps you can
even make it economical (ignoring time spent), if you can find a
"known/presumed broken" hulk on ePrey and pick it up cheap (inclusive of
shipping, border crud, etc) as a source of parts to build a user
interface, box, power supply etc from.

Win's partner-in-book's lab has this up, if you're interested, though I
think it's a bit out of date at this point in time:
http://seti.harvard.edu/synth/index.html
 
D

D from BC

Jan 1, 1970
0
Depends. If you are patient, you can get one at a better price simply by
sticking around and finding a week when nobody's bidding on them - at
least that *eventually* worked for me, and my cutoff point was a lot
lower than $300, so I let a whole bunch go for more money than I was
willing to put into them. I specifically did not want new and Chinese,
and I'm quite happy with my 3325A, LEDs and all. I have not found old
age to be an evil thing in well-built equipment, and 20 (up to 70,
actually, with some limitations) MHz is not a problem for my current
anticipated uses. I do wonder when I'm ever going to make use of the
0.000001 Hz end of the range; I am happy to have it, however, having run
into a situation with a client's generator where something below its 5
Hz bottom end would have been useful. It does a far better sweep, too.

Plenty of 3325s selling for well below $300. Don't actually see any
recent ones that got bid on (ie, more than one bid) selling for that
much. Couple with high starting prices that did get bought for $325 and
$399 with a single bid or BIN. One a couple of weeks back did get bid to
$301, but plenty selling a bit above and even a bit below $200 (not
really with shipping) in the past week. Also plenty of volume to
indicate that another will be along if you don't get the one you want at
the price you want to pay, if you can stand to wait.

Point being, by the time you've built the controls, power supplies,
output amps, connectors, boxes, etc. for your $30 chip, you'll probably
have spent more money on it. It will be newer, and perhaps it will go
faster, but the old one is a fully built system with a well-fleshed-out
user interface, etc. You can get new China junk to 20Mhz for $200 or
less, if you're willing to go there. Building your own, unless you're
sitting around looking for ways to fill your time, is something to do
for the experience or the bragging rights, or else to design the thing
well enough that you can sell them (built, as kits, board and a parts
list...) and make money at it - otherwise it's not "worthwhile". It need
only be "worthwhile" in one of those areas to be worth doing - it can be
a non-economical experiential job, for instance. And perhaps you can
even make it economical (ignoring time spent), if you can find a
"known/presumed broken" hulk on ePrey and pick it up cheap (inclusive of
shipping, border crud, etc) as a source of parts to build a user
interface, box, power supply etc from.

Win's partner-in-book's lab has this up, if you're interested, though I
think it's a bit out of date at this point in time:
http://seti.harvard.edu/synth/index.html


How about basic bare bones?

I was thinking of making a DDS PCB that interfaces to a PC.
No box.
Almost no controls.
Power supplies and output section is easy stuff.

The main work would be writing the control software for the PC.
And just my luck, I have some experience in this area.
Or, maybe there's an app floating in the wild.

Still.... It'll take me weeks develop. :(

But! Maybe I could put the kit on Eprey and make up all the lost time
with money..
I could probably sell it as low as $150.00.


D from BC
 
N

Nico Coesel

Jan 1, 1970
0
D from BC said:
I almost bought a HP 20Mhz synthesizer func gen.
which totaled up to $300.00 on Eprey.

It's so old.... it's got a 7 segment LED display. :p
It's so old...my hobby electronics are more high tech :p
It's so old...I feel sorry for the guy that won the bid.

I find it hard to justify spending $300.00 when a ~$30.00 2.7Ghz DDS
chip can probably make a wider range function generator.
http://www.analog.com/UploadedFiles/Data_Sheets/281281998AD9956_a.pdf

Question is...
Is it worthwhile to make a DIY DDS based function generator?

Depends on the amount of time you have. The biggest difficulty is
getting the programmable gain amplifier right to get various output
amplitudes. Expect to get to 10MHz (square wave) or so using off the
shelf parts.

My HP3314A (including the 3x output) was delivered yesterday. While it
is not DDS based, it has some really neat features you won't find on
most function generators.
 
N

Nico Coesel

Jan 1, 1970
0
D from BC said:
How about basic bare bones?

I was thinking of making a DDS PCB that interfaces to a PC.
No box.
Almost no controls.
Power supplies and output section is easy stuff.

The main work would be writing the control software for the PC.
And just my luck, I have some experience in this area.
Or, maybe there's an app floating in the wild.

Still.... It'll take me weeks develop. :(

But! Maybe I could put the kit on Eprey and make up all the lost time
with money..
I could probably sell it as low as $150.00.

Hmm, I have a design (USB based) waiting to be put on a PCB and tried
:)
 
D

D from BC

Jan 1, 1970
0
Hmm, I have a design (USB based) waiting to be put on a PCB and tried
:)

USB interface..Awesome! :)

Which DDS chip are you using?
Are you going to Ebay it?
How much would you sell a complete PCB?
Cost with and without an output gain/attenuation section?
Cost with and without control software?
Actually, I'll probably want the source code or write my own control
software.

Of course, assuming the DDS chip manufacturer doesn't have evaluation
boards for sale.

I think a modern PC controlled DDS signal generator on Ebay would blow
away lots old clunky generators or Asian boxes (probably XR2206 based)
in terms of price, range and quality.


D from BC
 
D

D from BC

Jan 1, 1970
0
Depends on the amount of time you have. The biggest difficulty is
getting the programmable gain amplifier right to get various output
amplitudes. Expect to get to 10MHz (square wave) or so using off the
shelf parts.

My HP3314A (including the 3x output) was delivered yesterday. While it
is not DDS based, it has some really neat features you won't find on
most function generators.

Let's see...a square wave with variable amplitude control, fast edges,
high frequency, low overshoot and low undershoot and driving a wide
range of impedances... ewwwww :p

How about using a power RF amplifier module?
D from BC
 
N

Nico Coesel

Jan 1, 1970
0
D from BC said:
USB interface..Awesome! :)

Which DDS chip are you using?
Are you going to Ebay it?
How much would you sell a complete PCB?
Cost with and without an output gain/attenuation section?
Cost with and without control software?
Actually, I'll probably want the source code or write my own control
software.

Of course, assuming the DDS chip manufacturer doesn't have evaluation
boards for sale.

I think a modern PC controlled DDS signal generator on Ebay would blow
away lots old clunky generators or Asian boxes (probably XR2206 based)
in terms of price, range and quality.

I think so too. Send me an e-mail. We'll talk there... Meanwhile I'll
dig up the specs.
 
J

JosephKK

Jan 1, 1970
0
D from BC [email protected] posted to sci.electronics.design:
Let's see...a square wave with variable amplitude control, fast
edges, high frequency, low overshoot and low undershoot and driving
a wide range of impedances... ewwwww :p

How about using a power RF amplifier module?
D from BC

Maybe, though a lot of them do not do well below 100 kHz.
 
Top