- or + 1.5 vdc on pin 5? Since you said the output is at -12 volts, I'll assume you measure it as -1.5 volts. If that is the case, the output of this op-amp, pin 7, should have ramped down to - 15 volts or so. Might be a bad op-amp.
Both of them the same at +37.5?
So 1.5 mA total tail...