Hi Mike,
Mike Coslo said:
I dunno, Joel. Are you saying that using a Ham radio to send email is
going to impress someone?
I'm saying that putting up a big sign saying, "Send e-mail here!" and
sitting people down in front of a computer (say... a mini Mac

running
Outlook or some similar easy-to-use mail client that pretty much anyone
(who's active on the Internet at all) can figure out how to use is a
considerably bigger help than putting up a sign saying, "Voice
communications relayed here!" and having a licensed ham sit there, take
someone's message, relay it to another ham outside the affected area, they
make a phone call to a family member (or whatever). The former just seems a
lot more efficient to me.
It just seems so odd to me that people who can now text message others
with their cell phones, and IM each other on a regular basis are going to
be impressed by a big HF setup.
Sure, if those people are actually in a city, interstate corridor, etc.,
where there's cell phone service. If not -- as folks into sailing the ocean
quickly find out -- suddenly having at least some low bandwidth e-mail
connection is a lot better than nothing.
I've posted before that my "grand vision" for amateur radio runs along the
lines of people within cities or major corridors using WiFi, EVDO/EDGE,
WiMax, etc. -- multi-megabit per second connections, that use ISM bands so
actually don't require hams at all to set them up, those who are
camping/hiking/traveling outside of such places using a presently
non-existant network of hilltop repeaters that operate at some many tens to
low hundreds of kilbits per second (128kbps is a favorite of mine) with,
e.g., 5W handheld radios, and those truly out in the "the middle of nowhere"
(the ocean, the outback, etc.) use HF at a couple kilobits per second.
Developing that "middle" ground of speed vs. coverage would do a lot to
relieve pressure on HF where of course there is so little specturm to begin
with; I have a suspicion that an awful lot of, e.g., WinLink traffic comes
from people who are still easily within range of being able to hit at least
a couple of hilltop repeaters with 5W or less.
---Joel